April 16, 2025

Trucking Companies Hiring: How to Choose the Right One (and Why It Matters More Than Ever)

Learn how to choose the right company for your trucking career goals.
Share this post

If you’ve spent any time looking for trucking jobs lately, you’ve seen the headlines: “Trucking companies hiring nationwide.” or “Driver shortage impacting trucking companies.” On paper, it looks like opportunity is everywhere. As a qualified CDL driver, you can driver anywhere you want, for any company, because they all need drivers. 

An experienced driver can see through that. When options are everywhere, the real question becomes how you’ll be treated once you’re hired  not how quickly a company can get you in a truck.

Just because a carrier is hiring doesn’t mean it’s worth your time, or your CDL, or your effort. The real question isn’t who’s hiring, it’s who’s hiring the right way. Who’s going to treat you with the respect you deserve? Who’s looking for a true partner, and not just a driver to fill a seat? 

This guide breaks down what actually matters when evaluating trucking companies hiring company drivers, owner-operators, and teams, and why more drivers are taking a closer look at carriers like Unlimited Carrier, where respect and long-term stability matter as much as freight volume.

Why “Now Hiring” Doesn’t Mean “Good Place to Work”

Turnover in trucking remains high across the industry. Turnover in trucking is ridiculously high, hovering around 90% according to the American Trucking Association. One of the biggest reasons? Too many companies focus on filling seats instead of building careers.

When a company’s business model depends on constant hiring, drivers become replaceable. That mindset shows up fast once you’re on the road. Ask yourself, how many times have you talked to a driver manager who didn’t know your name? A dispatch coordinator who cared more about the freight than they care about you?

Common reasons drivers walk away from the wrong carrier include:

  • Home time that isn’t honored. It’s promised during recruiting, then quietly pushed aside when “one more load” turns into a pattern. Missed family time adds up fast.

  • Pay that sounds good on paper but doesn’t hold up week to week. Mileage pay, bonuses, and incentives look strong in ads, but inconsistent freight, unpaid delays, or unrealistic bonus thresholds tell a different story once you’re running.

  • Dispatch that feels adversarial instead of supportive. When communication turns into pressure, guilt, or threats, especially around load acceptance, trust disappears.

  • Equipment problems that become the driver’s burden. Deferred maintenance, slow repairs, and being blamed for breakdowns create stress that experienced drivers won’t tolerate.

  • Being treated like a truck number instead of a professional. When concerns are dismissed, policies are inflexible, and leadership feels unreachable, drivers know exactly where they stand.

That’s why smart, experienced drivers (like yourself) slow down and ask better questions before signing on. They know that choosing the right carrier isn’t about who hires the fastest, it’s about who’s still worth driving for six months, a year, or five years down the road.

What to Look for in Trucking Companies Hiring Today

Drawing from industry best practices, and what experienced drivers consistently say matters most, here are the core areas worth paying attention to. When you’re looking for a CDL job, keep these core areas in mind:

Pay That’s Clear, Attainable, and Honest

Good carriers don’t hide behind vague promises. They’re transparent and honest. If they say you’ll earn a particular CPM, that’s what you earn, at minimum. The second a carrier gets fuzzy on your pay details, walk away. 

For company drivers, you should be able to understand:

  • CPM rate

  • Bonus structure

  • How often bonuses are actually paid

  • Benefits cost and start date

At Unlimited Carrier, company drivers earn $0.60 per mile, with eligibility for a $0.05 per mile monthly safety bonus. In 2025 alone, we paid out $253,000 in safety bonuses. Our drivers earned every single penny of that, and we were honored to pay it. 

More Unlimited Carrier Benefits include:

  • Medical, dental, vision, life, and disability coverage

  • 401(k) with company match

  • 60% of the premium covered by the company

Drivers also earn:

  • A $2,000 referral bonus per successful hire, paid in full with no cap

  • One week of vacation after 90 days, with PTO increasing over time

That kind of structure tells you something important: the company expects drivers to stay.

Owner Operator Jobs: Why the Right Carrier Partnership Makes the Difference

Not all owner operator jobs are structured the same, and the differences matter more than most recruiting ads let on. For owner-operators, choosing a carrier is about finding a partner that supports your business model, respects your independence, and understands the financial realities of running a truck.

When evaluating owner operator jobs, it’s important to look beyond percentage splits and upfront incentives and ask practical, long-term questions:

  • Do you have control over your revenue goals and weekly expectations?

  • Are you free to operate as an independent business, or required to follow a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach?

  • Is maintenance support proactive, helping reduce downtime, or reactive, leaving you to absorb the cost of delays?

Many owner-operators discover too late that some owner operator jobs come with hidden limitations like restricted flexibility, unclear communication, or support that fades once the truck is under dispatch. Over time, those issues can limit earning potential and increase operating stress.

At Unlimited Carrier, owner operator jobs are built around true partnership. Owner-operators are treated as business owners, not leased equipment, and the structure is designed to support sustainable, long-term success.

Owner-operators working with Unlimited Carrier:

  • Take home 75% of gross revenue, allowing income to scale with productivity
  • Receive a $2,500 sign-on bonus, paid within the first five months, or have the option of free plates (IPR)
  • Benefit from a $0.15 per gallon fuel discount, helping control one of the largest ongoing operating costs
  • Enjoy our exclusive maintenance discounts for Owner-Operators, with the lowest labor rates around at just $75/hour, a generous discount on parts, and free supplies and gear, cutting your maintenance costs and helping your protect your most valuable asset.
  • Set weekly revenue targets directly with leadership, ensuring business goals align with real-world freight conditions

Maintenance support is handled proactively through Unlimited Carrier’s in-house shop, Truck Service Point, with My Fleet Assist providing 24/7 roadside assistance. This approach helps keep trucks moving and downtime predictable, allowing owner-operators to focus on running their business instead of managing constant disruptions.

For owner-operators looking for jobs that offer transparency, operational support, and respect for independence, structure matters.

Home Time That Respects Your Goals

There’s no one-size-fits-all version of home time. Some drivers want to maximize miles. Some want to be home daily, and some want to be OTR for weeks. Others want more balance. What matters is whether the company respects your priorities without forcing you into their box. 

Unlimited Carrier operates with no freight shortage, meaning drivers can:

  • Run harder and longer when income is the priority

  • Pull back when home time matters more

  • Set expectations directly with their Division Leader

There’s no forced dispatch, and drivers can say no without punishment, a major red flag checkmark in today’s market.

Dispatch That Works With You, Not Against You

Ask any seasoned driver: dispatch can make or break a job.

At many trucking companies hiring drivers, dispatch is structured around maximizing truck utilization, often at the expense of the driver. When that happens, communication becomes transactional instead of collaborative, and problems tend to compound quickly. This disrespect to CDL drivers pushes them out of otherwise good companies. 

At better carriers, dispatch is a partnership:

  • Dispatchers and planners collaborate with drivers

  • Communication is direct

  • Saying “no” doesn’t put a target on your back

Unlimited Carrier takes a different approach. Dispatch is built around mutual respect and accountability, with the understanding that drivers are professionals managing real-world variables every day.

At Unlimited Carrier:

  • There is no forced dispatch, allowing drivers to make informed decisions about the loads they accept

  • Driver input is respected, especially when it comes to scheduling, home time, and operational concerns

  • Drivers have open-door access to leadership, not just recruiters or intermediaries

This structure is reinforced by the fact that Unlimited Carrier’s ownership team started their careers as drivers. That background shapes how policies are created and how issues are handled. Decisions are informed by firsthand experience — not just spreadsheets or utilization metrics.

The Bottom Line: Choosing the Right Trucking Company to Drive For

If you’re evaluating trucking companies hiring drivers right now, the smartest move usually isn’t chasing the largest sign-on bonus or the most aggressive advertising. Those offers can be tempting, but they rarely tell you how day-to-day operations actually work once the truck is assigned and the miles start counting.

A better approach is to slow down and ask a few practical questions that experienced drivers know matter over time:

  • Will I be treated like a professional, not just a truck number?

  • Can I realistically earn what’s being promised, week after week?

  • Do my personal and financial goals factor into how this company operates?

The answers to those questions tend to reveal more about a carrier than any recruiting slogan ever will. They show whether a company is focused on long-term relationships or short-term turnover, and whether drivers are viewed as partners in the operation or simply as capacity to be replaced.

For company drivers, owner-operators, and team drivers who value straight answers, consistent freight, and a work environment built on mutual respect, Unlimited Carrier is worth a closer look. Not because it’s the loudest option — but because it’s structured to be a stable one.

Learn more about driving with Unlimited Carrier when you’re ready, on your terms, not anyone else’s.